I Never Know WhatLuke 2:19

Four Vague Words In A Note On My Phone

This message is for the man who keeps a note all year for exactly this and opens it in December to find four words too vague to use, and blames himself rather than the noticing

You are more organized about this than most people alive.

There is a note. It has a title. You made it in a hopeful moment two or three years ago and you have added to it, on and off, ever since.

And every December you open it, and there it is.

Four words. Maybe six. Something like: likes cooking. Something like: mentioned a trip. Something like: the blue one.

And you sit there staring at your own handwriting from March and you cannot remember one single thing about what you meant.

So the note goes back in the drawer of the phone and you go and do what you were always going to do, and somewhere in there you decide that you are the sort of person who cannot even keep a note properly.

That is the part I want to argue with, because the note is not the failure. The note is nearly right.

Mary kept all these things

There is a sentence about a woman keeping things that has been sitting in the middle of a Christmas story for two thousand years.

But Mary kept all these things, and pondered them in her heart. (Luke 2:19, King James Version)

Kept, and pondered. Two separate activities, and the first one is the one nobody notices.

She kept them. That is a holding on to, deliberate, at the time, in the middle of the event rather than afterward. Shepherds came in and said a great deal and everybody around her marveled and went home, and she did something none of them did. She kept it.

You have the same instinct that woman had, and Luke 2:19 puts the keeping down as a thing a person does on purpose rather than as a memory that happens to survive. The Holy Spirit is the one who made a habit of keeping worth writing into the account at all, and He wrote it in without one word of explanation.

Now the second verb, which is where the trouble hides.

Pondered them. Not pondered a summary of them. Not pondered the general area they belonged to. She turned the actual things over.

And you cannot turn over four words. There is nothing there to turn.

You are not short of the will to keep things, and it is written that she kept all these things rather than a note about them. The Spirit of God is the one who separates a keeping from a filing, and the difference between those two is the whole of what has gone wrong here.

Here is the plain version of it.

The note in your phone is a filing system. It has categories in it. Likes cooking is a category. Mentioned a trip is a category. And a category in December is a locked door, because the thing that made it worth writing down was never the category.

You have been storing the label instead of the thing, and His word is careful to say she kept the things themselves. The Holy Spirit is the one who has kept the actual moment alive in you for years even while the note went cold, which is why you can feel that something was there.

Keep the sentence, not the subject

So here is the change, and it costs nothing and takes eleven seconds.

Write what they said. Their words. The actual sentence, or as near to it as you can get, and the month.

Not: likes cooking.

But: said in June that she has always wanted to be able to make her grandmother's bread and does not know where to start.

Read those two again, side by side. The first one is a shelf you cannot reach. The second one is somebody's whole heart, sitting there in the open, and anybody could build something out of it.

You are eleven seconds away from a note that works, and Luke 2:19 shows a woman keeping the words themselves and turning them over later. The Spirit of God is the one who makes an ordinary sentence in June still warm in December, and He does that through the writing rather than around it.

And there is a second half to it. Put the month.

The month tells you whether it was a passing thing or a returning one. If the same subject shows up in March and again in September, that is not a preference, that is a longing, and a longing is the most useful thing a person can ever hand you without meaning to.

You are collecting evidence rather than ideas, and it is written that she pondered them, which is what a person does with things they actually still have. The Holy Spirit is the one who lines two dates up in a man's mind and makes him see what neither one showed on its own.

The note was never for December

One more thing, and it is the part that will change how the whole year feels.

The reason the note fails is that it has been written for a future emergency. It gets opened once, under pressure, in the one month when the mind is least able to reconstruct anything.

That is the wrong job for it. Nothing kept that way survives.

Mary did not keep those things in order to solve a problem eleven months later. She kept them because they were worth keeping, and the keeping was its own act, done at the time, with the shepherds still standing in the room.

You have been asking a note to do a job it was never built for, and Luke 2:19 puts the keeping in the middle of the moment rather than at the far end of it. The Spirit of God is the one who makes a man notice something while it is still happening, and that noticing has been going on in you all along.

So write it when it happens. In the car, at the counter, standing in a hallway with the phone already in your hand.

And then leave it alone. Do not go back and tidy it, do not turn it into a plan, and do not judge it. The keeping is finished the second the words are down.

You are done the moment the sentence is written, and it is written that she kept them first and pondered them afterward. The Holy Spirit is the one who does the pondering part with a man later, and He does not need help with the timing of it.

And when December comes, the note will not be four words. It will be nine or ten sentences in other people's own voices, and the only difficulty left is choosing.

You have a good year of listening already behind you, and the written word calls the keeping of things a woman's own deliberate act rather than a lucky memory. The Spirit of God is the one who has been putting these sentences in front of you all year long, and He has not been doing it for nothing.

The breakthrough

So here is what I believe is going out over a man looking at six useless words in a phone.

You have been doing the right thing badly rather than the wrong thing well, and a gift has never once needed to be clever to be right. Luke 2:19 says Mary kept all these things and pondered them in her heart, and the Holy Spirit is the one who gave you the instinct to keep anything at all.

And this, which is the word I came with.

You are not a man who does not pay attention, and no four word note anywhere has ever been able to prove what a man has been noticing all year. It is written that she kept the things themselves, and the Spirit of God is turning a locked category into somebody's actual sentence written down in June.

Write what they said. That is the whole change.

Declare this over yourself

  1. Four vague words from March, you are not a report on how much I notice the people around me. Luke 2:19 says Mary kept all these things and pondered them in her heart, so by the Holy Spirit I write the next sentence down in their words with the month, in the name of Jesus.
  2. Verdict that says I cannot even keep a note, you have never once been the truth about me. The written word calls keeping a deliberate act done in the moment rather than a memory that survives, and by the Holy Spirit I keep the thing itself and stop filing the label.
  3. Father, You have been putting their own sentences in front of me all year and I wrote down the category instead. Your word says she kept all these things, so by Your Spirit I catch the next one whole, and I leave it alone until it is needed.

Why we ask you to say these out loud

The word this stands on

Luke 2:19

This message is free, and always will be. There is nothing to unlock, nothing to subscribe to, and nothing you owe for having received it.

More Manna

Proverbs 25:11
I Never Know What

Brilliant For Strangers And Frozen For My Mother

Never Know10 minImani
Proverbs 25:11
Romans 12:10
I Never Know What

I Ask My Wife What To Give My Own Friends

Never Know10 minCaleb
Romans 12:10
2 Corinthians 8:12
I Never Know What

I Buy For The Person I Wish She Was

Never Know10 minNova
2 Corinthians 8:12
1 Samuel 16:7
I Never Know What

I Cannot Name One Thing My Brother Likes

Never Know10 minAmir
1 Samuel 16:7
Ephesians 2:10
I Never Know What

I Decided A Long Time Ago I Am Bad At This

Never Know10 minZev
Ephesians 2:10
Proverbs 20:5
I Never Know What

I Stand There Every Year With No Idea

Never Know10 minSantiago
Proverbs 20:5
Isaiah 50:4
I Never Know What

I Used To Be Able To Tell By Looking

Never Know10 minEliana
Isaiah 50:4
Proverbs 27:23
I Never Know What

I Used To Know What My Grandchildren Wanted

Never Know10 minElias
Proverbs 27:23
Philippians 2:4
I Never Know What

Nine Years Of The Same Thing For My Sister

Never Know9 minMelody
Philippians 2:4
Galatians 6:4
I Never Know What

Somebody Always Gives The Better One

Never Know10 minZariah
Galatians 6:4
Psalm 139:1
I Never Know What

They Always Say Anything Is Fine

Never Know9 minJubilee
Psalm 139:1
Psalm 127:2
Less To Spend

A Number On A Piece Of Paper In My Drawer

Less To Spend10 minZev
Psalm 127:2
Ephesians 5:16
They Have Everything

All I Have That He Does Not Is Time

They Have Everything10 minZev
Ephesians 5:16
Proverbs 24:16
The Gift Missed

Eleven Years Since I Gave Her Anything

The Gift Missed10 minEliana
Proverbs 24:16
Exodus 31:3
Made Not Bought

Her House Is Full Of Better Made Things

Made Not Bought10 minJubilee
Exodus 31:3
2 Samuel 18:33
Given Without Return

Eleven Years Of Giving And Then A Funeral

Given Without Return10 minNova
2 Samuel 18:33
1 Thessalonians 2:8
Present Not Presents

Every Visit I Make Has A Job In It

Present Not Presents10 minElias
1 Thessalonians 2:8
Ecclesiastes 11:4
Less To Spend

I Decided To Give Nothing At All This Year

Less To Spend10 minCaleb
Ecclesiastes 11:4
1 Corinthians 13:3
They Have Everything

Giving To My Friend Has Become A Performance

They Have Everything10 minJubilee
1 Corinthians 13:3
Proverbs 17:9
The Gift Missed

I Accidentally Named The Thing She Was Ashamed Of

The Gift Missed10 minJubilee
Proverbs 17:9
John 21:9
Made Not Bought

I Cooked For Them And Could Not Sit Down

Made Not Bought10 minAmir
John 21:9
Matthew 6:4
Given Without Return

Everybody Knows Except The One I Give To

Given Without Return10 minTahoma
Matthew 6:4
Psalm 16:11
Present Not Presents

I Am In The Chair And Not In The Room

Present Not Presents10 minAmir
Psalm 16:11
Proverbs 10:19
Less To Spend

I Explained It Before She Even Opened It

Less To Spend10 minNova
Proverbs 10:19
Acts 3:6
They Have Everything

He Buys Himself Whatever He Wants

They Have Everything10 minNova
Acts 3:6
Romans 8:1
The Gift Missed

I Apologized Until The Apology Was The Gift

The Gift Missed9 minImani
Romans 8:1
1 Corinthians 12:6
Made Not Bought

I Have Never Made Anything Before

Made Not Bought10 minZev
1 Corinthians 12:6
Psalm 116:12
Given Without Return

He Never Could Give Back And I Still Mind

Given Without Return10 minElias
Psalm 116:12
Proverbs 18:13
Present Not Presents

I Am In The Room And On The Phone

Present Not Presents10 minImani
Proverbs 18:13
1 Timothy 6:6
Less To Spend

I Have Always Been The Generous One

Less To Spend10 minElias
1 Timothy 6:6
Psalm 145:4
They Have Everything

He Has More At Nineteen Than I Had At Sixty

They Have Everything10 minElias
Psalm 145:4
Psalm 34:5
The Gift Missed

I Found Out It Had Been Given Away

The Gift Missed10 minTahoma
Psalm 34:5
Exodus 35:25
Made Not Bought

I Made It And Then Panicked

Made Not Bought10 minImani
Exodus 35:25
Luke 6:35
Given Without Return

I Give Every Year And Nothing Comes Back

Given Without Return10 minZev
Luke 6:35
Luke 10:41
Present Not Presents

I Fill Every Visit Up With Doing

Present Not Presents10 minJubilee
Luke 10:41